Makeup sets range from compact face palettes to large kits stocked with brushes and color cosmetics, so the right choice depends on how much variety you need and who will use it. I rank the LAURA GELLER Best of the Best Baked Palette as the best overall for its focused full-face format, while the Sephora Favorites Prep & Set stands out for a skincare-and-primer routine and the Revolution 24-Piece Advent Calendar for giftable variety. The main tradeoff is breadth versus usefulness: a large kit can cover more looks, but may include colors or tools that go unused. Smaller sets are easier to store and work into a routine, though they offer less range. Read on for the full comparison and guidance on choosing a set that fits your experience, routine, and gifting needs.
Turn your wind-down time into listening time
- Thousands of audiobooks, podcasts and originals
- Listen on your phone, tablet or Echo — also offline
- Cancel anytime
Key Takeaways
- The LAURA GELLER palette is the most focused full-face pick: its palette format favors a curated routine over the numerous individual items in the larger kits.
- Sephora Favorites serves a different purpose from color-heavy sets: its skincare and primer emphasis makes it the clearest choice for prep and setting rather than building a broad makeup wardrobe.
- The Revolution Advent Calendar is the most gift-oriented option: its 24-piece format offers variety, but buyers seeking a practical everyday kit may prefer a more targeted set.
- The two beginner and all-in-one kits trade curation for breadth: foundations, eye products, lip products, brushes, and bags can provide a starting assortment, but a broad bundle may contain items the recipient does not use.
- Large item counts do not automatically mean better fit: the 40-color kit and MTDXILTAI set prioritize assortment, while the best choice depends on usable shades, tools, storage, and the recipient’s routine.
More Details on Our Top Picks
All In One Makeup Kit for Teen Girls Beginners with Foundation, Eyeshadow, Lipstick, Eyeliner, Mascara, Brushes, Bag, Travel Friendly MakeUp Gift Set, Birthday Gifts for Teen Girls, Graduation Gifts
This kit earns its place as a straightforward starter set: it combines foundation, eye and lip products, brushes, and a bag, so a beginner can try a complete routine without piecing together separate purchases. Its travel-friendly packaging also makes it easier to keep the basics together for touch-ups. Compared with the MTDXILTAI All-in-One Makeup Kit, it appears less focused on sheer volume—the MTDXILTAI includes two 14-color palettes and 20 brushes—so this is the more approachable choice for someone who wants core categories rather than an overflowing assortment. The tradeoff is limited shade detail: foundation and color choices may not suit every complexion or preference. It is also a broad kit rather than a tailored match for a particular skin type, so buyers with specific formula needs should check product details before choosing.
Pros:- Includes foundation, eyeshadow, lipstick, eyeliner, and mascara for a full basic routine
- Brushes and a travel bag keep the kit’s components together
- Beginner-friendly breadth avoids the larger brush count and palette assortment of the MTDXILTAI kit
- Described as waterproof and long-lasting
Cons:- Limited shade information makes complexion and color matching uncertain
- The number of included categories may exceed what a minimalist needs
- Some formulas may not suit every skin type
Best for: Teen beginners or gift buyers seeking one portable kit with core face, eye, and lip categories.
Not ideal for: Minimalists who only want a few products, or buyers who need clearly specified foundation shades and formulas for a particular skin type.
- Includes:Foundation, eyeshadow, lipstick, eyeliner, mascara, brushes, travel bag
- Intended users:Beginners and professionals
- Formula claims:Waterproof, long-lasting, vibrant color, skin-friendly
- Packaging:Travel-friendly
- Makeup categories:Face, eyes, and lips
- Gift occasions:Birthday and graduation
Our verdict“Choose this as a portable first kit for a teen or beginner who wants core makeup categories in one package, but not as a shade-customized set.”
Revolution Makeup 2025 Advent Calendar, 24-Piece Beauty Gift Set for Lips, Eyes, & Face, Vegan & Cruelty-Free
The Revolution calendar stands apart through 24 varied pieces spanning lips, eyes, and face, making it a stronger pick for discovery than for building a predictable everyday routine. Its mix of glosses, lipsticks, highlighters, mascaras, liners, brushes, and sponges gives a recipient multiple product types to try, while the vegan and cruelty-free claims may matter to shoppers choosing a gift around those preferences. Compared with the Sephora Favorites Prep & Set, which concentrates on skincare, primer, hydration, and setting, Revolution puts more emphasis on color cosmetics and tools. That breadth comes with uncertainty: individual shades and product sizes are not detailed, and the curated assortment may include items that do not fit a recipient’s tastes. Choose it for variety, not for a carefully matched shade selection.
Pros:- 24-piece assortment covers lips, eyes, face, and tools
- Includes brushes and sponges alongside cosmetics
- Vegan and cruelty-free cosmetics
- Offers more color-product variety than the skincare-focused Sephora Favorites Prep & Set
Cons:- Individual shades and product sizes are not specified in the provided details
- Some items may not match the recipient’s preferences
- A broad assortment may be less useful than a focused everyday set
Best for: Gift shoppers looking for a vegan and cruelty-free assortment of lip, eye, face, and tool products for someone who enjoys trying variety.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need specified shades, dependable product sizes, or a focused routine built around skin prep and setting.
- Number of pieces:24
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-free:Yes
- Lip products:Lip glosses and lipsticks
- Other cosmetics:Highlighters, mascaras, and liners
- Tools:Brushes and sponges
Our verdict“Pick this for a recipient who values discovering varied vegan color cosmetics more than choosing exact shades or a targeted routine.”
Sephora Favorites Prep & Set 9-Piece Makeup Set – Skincare & Primer Essentials
This is the most routine-focused set in the lineup: its nine prep-and-set products combine primers, mists, setting powder, skincare, and SPF rather than trying to supply every color category. Two full-size products, five travel minis, and two deluxe essentials make it useful for sampling a coordinated prep routine while keeping several items travel-ready. Compared with Revolution’s 24-piece calendar, it offers less color variety but a clearer purpose: preparing skin and helping makeup look finished. That focus also limits its appeal as a standalone makeup set; it does not list staples such as lipstick, eyeliner, or eyeshadow. The assortment includes several different formulations, which may take some sorting for a beginner, and suitability can vary by skin type and tone. It makes more sense for someone who already owns color makeup.
Pros:- Focused combination of primers, hydrating mists, setting powder, and SPF
- Mix of two full-size, five mini, and two deluxe products supports trial and travel
- Includes products intended to prep, hydrate, and set makeup
- More routine-specific than the broader Revolution advent calendar
Cons:- Does not provide a full selection of color makeup such as lipstick or eyeshadow
- Multiple product types may be difficult for beginners to coordinate
- Formulations may not suit every skin type or tone
Best for: Beauty enthusiasts who already have color cosmetics and want a mixed-size set for skin prep, hydration, SPF, and setting.
Not ideal for: Beginners seeking a complete color makeup kit, or shoppers who need products tailored to a specific skin type or tone.
- Number of pieces:9
- Size mix:2 full-size, 5 mini travel sizes, 2 deluxe essentials
- Benefit Primer:0.75 fl oz
- First Aid Beauty Daily Treatment Pads:3.2 oz
- Glow Recipe Highlighting Serum:0.5 fl oz
- LYS Beauty Translucent Pressed Setting Powder:0.23 oz
- Makeup by Mario Hydrating Setting Mist:1.7 fl oz
- Tower28 Beauty Mineral SPF:SPF 30; 0.68 fl oz
- Other listed products:Isle of Paradise Liquid Bronzing Serum (Golden Hour), 0.27 fl oz; MERIT Lightweight Cream, 0.5 fl oz; Summer Fridays Hydrating Mist, 1 fl oz
Our verdict“Choose this if your color makeup collection is already in place and you want a curated set centered on prepping and setting.”
LAURA GELLER Best of the Best Baked Palette – Full Face Palette
Unlike the multi-item kits here, the LAURA GELLER palette condenses complexion color into one travel-friendly compact with blush, bronzer, highlighter, and three eyeshadows. That makes it a practical choice for someone who wants coordinated face and eye powders without carrying brushes, tubes, and multiple palettes in a bag. Its baked formula is described as crease-proof and designed to avoid settling into fine lines, giving this set a more specific focus than the all-in-one kits for teens or the MTDXILTAI set with its liquid products and 20 brushes. The compromise is range: it does not include foundation, mascara, or lip color, and the limited shade variety may not work across different skin tones. Blending may also take some effort, so it is less of a ready-made complete routine.
Pros:- Combines blush, bronzer, highlighter, and eyeshadows in one compact
- Travel-friendly format is simpler to carry than a large bagged kit
- Baked formula is described as crease-proof and designed for mature skin
- More compact than the MTDXILTAI kit with its 20 brushes and multiple palettes
Cons:- Does not include foundation, mascara, lip products, or application tools
- Limited shade variety may not suit every skin tone
- May require blending to achieve the desired finish
Best for: Mature-skin shoppers who want a compact selection of face powders and eyeshadows for travel or a streamlined routine.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a full makeup kit with foundation, mascara, lip products, or a wider choice of shades.
- Number of eyeshadows:3
- Included face products:Blush, bronzer, highlighter
- Formulation:Baked
- Manufacturing detail:Artisan-made in Italy
- Intended audience:Older women and mature skin
- Wear claims:Crease-proof and all-day wear
- Format:Travel-friendly compact
Our verdict“Pick this compact if you want a travel-ready face-and-eye palette for mature skin, not a complete makeup set.”
MTDXILTAI All-in-One Makeup Kit with Storage Bag, 2×14 Color Eyeshadow Palette, Liquid Foundation, Eyeliner Pencils, Contouring Stick, Lip Gloss, and 20 Brushes (Black)
For shoppers who want the widest working assortment in this group, the MTDXILTAI set is the clear volume pick: it lists 28 eyeshadow shades, five lip glosses, three foundation styles, and 20 brushes, plus contour, brow, and eye products. That tool count gives a beginner room to try different application approaches, while more experienced users may appreciate having multiple product categories together. Compared with the teen-focused all-in-one kit, this option provides a much larger palette and brush selection; compared with the compact LAURA GELLER palette, it is a full bagged collection rather than a carry-light color edit. The tradeoff is bulk and complexity. With so many components, it is less convenient for travel and may be harder for a newcomer to sort through. The supplied details also do not specify foundation shades, so matching needs attention.
Pros:- Two 14-color palettes provide 28 eyeshadow shades
- Includes 20 brushes plus powder puffs for a range of application tasks
- Covers face, eye, lip, and brow products, including three foundation styles
- Storage bag keeps the larger assortment together
Cons:- The many products may overwhelm beginners who want a simple routine
- Bulkier and less travel-friendly than the LAURA GELLER compact
- Foundation shade details are not provided
Best for: Makeup learners or enthusiasts who want many color options and a large brush assortment in one organized set.
Not ideal for: Minimalists, frequent travelers seeking a compact kit, or buyers who require clearly specified foundation shades.
- Storage bag:Included
- Eyeshadow palettes:2 palettes with 14 colors each
- Lip gloss:5 pieces
- Foundation styles:3
- Mascara:1
- Eyebrow products:1 eyebrow pencil and 1 eyebrow powder
- Other face and eye items:1 eyeliner, 1 contour stick, 2 powder puffs
- Makeup brushes:20
- Color:Black
Our verdict“Choose this set if breadth and brushes matter more than portability or a simple, shade-specific routine.”
All-in-One Makeup Kit for Women – Full Cosmetic Gift Set Includes Eyeshadow Palette, Foundation, Eyeliner, Contour Stick, Lip Gloss & Brush Set
The PEENICE kit earns its place for buyers who want a broad, coordinated collection rather than a few interchangeable basics. Its three eyeshadow palettes, six lipsticks, face products, brushes, and makeup bag cover more stages of a routine than the focused Sephora Favorites Prep & Set 9-Piece Makeup Set, which concentrates on skincare and primer essentials. Two foundations and a concealer palette also give this set more complexion options, though the product details do not specify shades, so matching may take some guesswork. The included eyebrow stencils and brush set add useful tools for experimenting, but the volume can feel like clutter if you usually wear only a few products. This is a better fit for a gift recipient building a makeup stash than for someone seeking a compact everyday edit.
Pros:- Covers face, eye, and lip makeup along with application tools
- Includes three eyeshadow palettes and six lipsticks for variety
- Comes with a makeup bag for keeping the assortment together
- Listed as vegan and cruelty-free
Cons:- The large assortment may be excessive for a simple daily routine
- Foundation and palette shade details are not provided
- The breadth of products may take time for a beginner to sort through
Best for: Gift buyers choosing a broad face, eye, and lip collection for someone who wants to explore different makeup looks.
Not ideal for: Minimal-makeup users or shoppers who need clearly specified foundation shades and a small, streamlined everyday kit.
- Eyeshadow palettes:3
- Foundation:2 pieces
- Lipsticks:6
- Face products:Loose powder, face primer, contour stick, concealer palette, and contour palette
- Eye products:Eyeliner, eyebrow pencil, 10 eyebrow stencils, and mascara
- Application tools:Makeup brush set and 2 makeup sponges
- Storage:1 makeup bag
- Product claims:Cruelty-free and vegan
Our verdict“Choose this kit as a gift for someone who wants a broad makeup collection and is comfortable sorting through many products.”
Makeup Kit for Women: Complete 40-Color Eyeshadow Palette, Foundation, Lipstick, and Makeup Tools
This kit is the stronger choice for shoppers who want color options to lead the purchase: its 40-, 20-, and 10-color eyeshadow palettes offer more stated eye-shade variety than the PEENICE kit’s three palettes, whose color counts are not specified. The lineup also extends well beyond eyeshadow, with a 15-color concealer palette, two foundations, lip products, setting spray, and application tools. That range can suit someone building a versatile collection, while the portable bag gives the many pieces a place to go. The tradeoff is complexity: compared with the more straightforward LAURA GELLER Best of the Best Baked Palette, this is a much larger assortment to learn and organize. Shade counts are clear, but foundation shades and individual product formats are not, which may make complexion matching less predictable.
Pros:- Three eyeshadow palettes provide 70 listed color options in total
- 15-color concealer palette adds complexion-shade variety
- Includes setting spray, blush, primer, and application accessories
- Portable cosmetic bag supports storage and travel
Cons:- The number of products and colors may overwhelm casual users
- Foundation shade details are not specified
- The broad assortment may be harder to organize than a single full-face palette
Best for: Makeup hobbyists who want multiple eyeshadow color ranges plus face products and tools in one travel-ready collection.
Not ideal for: Complete beginners who prefer a short, curated routine or shoppers who need detailed foundation shade information before choosing.
- Eyeshadow palettes:40 colors, 20 colors, and 10 colors
- Concealer palette:15 colors
- Foundation:2 pieces
- Contour powder:3 colors
- Lip products:2 lipsticks and 5 lip glosses
- Additional face and eye products:Primer, pressed powder, blush, eyeliner, mascara, eyebrow pencil, and setting spray
- Accessories:Eyelash curler, stencils, makeup sponges, and brushes
- Storage:Portable cosmetic bag
Our verdict“Pick this set if eyeshadow variety and a wide range of supporting products matter more than a simple, beginner-focused routine.”
How We Picked
I compared these makeup sets by how well each serves a distinct buying need: everyday use, beginner practice, gifting, face-prep routines, or a wide color assortment. I looked at the stated contents and format, including whether a set centers on a palette, prep products, or a mix of complexion, eye, lip, and tool items. I also weighed usability factors such as storage, portability, and how easy it may be to make a coherent routine from the included products.
The ranking favors clear purpose and practical usefulness over the biggest item count. The LAURA GELLER palette leads as a focused full-face option; Sephora Favorites and Revolution rank highly for their distinct prep and gifting roles. Broader kits remain relevant for beginners and shoppers who want many product types together, but rank lower when their large assortments make shade fit and actual use harder to predict. Since product details do not establish individual shade suitability or performance, I treat those as buyer checks rather than assumed strengths.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Makeup Sets
Before choosing a set, I would match its format to the routine the recipient actually wants. These kits differ less by the word “complete” than by what they prioritize: prep, a compact face palette, giftable variety, or a large starter assortment.
Choose a set by routine, not item count
A kit with many components can seem like the safest choice, but extra products only help when they suit the user’s habits. Start by listing the steps the recipient already does or wants to learn, such as eyeshadow, complexion, or makeup prep. A palette-led set may make a short routine easier to organize, while a mixed kit offers more categories at once. One common mistake is choosing a large bundle as a substitute for knowing what products are needed. If several included types are unlikely to be used, a narrower set may offer a better experience. For a gift, prioritize a clear use case over a high piece count.
Check complexion shade fit before buying
Foundation and contour can be the hardest parts of a makeup set to buy for someone else because shade match depends on more than a general light, medium, or deep label. If the listing does not give enough shade detail, treat complexion products as a possible bonus rather than the main reason to choose that kit. A set focused on eyes, lips, or a palette may be an easier gift when you do not know the recipient’s complexion. Buyers choosing an all-in-one kit for themselves should check shade options and return terms before relying on its foundation. A broad collection cannot solve a poor match. This is one reason a smaller, more focused set can be a safer purchase.
Balance variety against color usability
Large eyeshadow assortments give users more shades to experiment with, but the number of colors says little about whether those shades suit a particular person’s style. Think about whether the recipient prefers neutral everyday looks, vivid experimentation, or a mix. A 40-color palette may appeal to someone who enjoys trying different combinations, while a more curated format can reduce decision fatigue. For a beginner, too many similar or unfamiliar shades can make a kit less approachable rather than more useful. Check product images and shade descriptions for colors the user is likely to wear. Favor a useful range over an impressive count.
Decide whether included tools and storage matter
Brushes, bags, and cases can make an all-in-one set easier to carry or give, but their presence does not tell you how comfortable or durable they are. Consider whether the recipient already owns tools and whether the kit needs to travel. A compact palette can take less space than a set with many separate products, while a bag may help keep a larger assortment together. A frequent buying mistake is treating “tools included” as proof that no other supplies will be needed. Check what tools are actually listed and whether the storage format suits the user’s routine. If portability is a priority, compactness may matter more than extra pieces.
Pay more for a better match, not a bigger bundle
When deciding between a focused set and a broad kit, look at how much of the collection will have a role in the recipient’s routine. A more targeted palette or prep set may make more sense than a bundle padded with categories the buyer does not need. Conversely, someone building a first collection may appreciate having several product types in one package. For gifts, a distinctive format such as an advent calendar can add a sense of discovery, though it may not be the most efficient everyday choice. Compare the contents against the intended use before treating more products as better value. The best purchase is the one with the least mismatch between its contents and the user.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which of these makeup sets is the safest gift if I do not know the recipient’s foundation shade?
I would avoid making foundation the deciding feature when you do not know the recipient’s complexion or shade preferences. The LAURA GELLER palette is a more focused option, while the Revolution Advent Calendar offers a gift-led mix of products. The Sephora Favorites set may suit someone interested in skincare and primer more than color cosmetics. Before buying any set with complexion products, check whether the listed shades are specific or whether multiple options are available. A gift that matches the recipient’s routine is usually a safer bet than one chosen for its broad product count.
Are large all-in-one makeup kits a good choice for someone just starting out?
They can be useful when a beginner wants to try several product categories without assembling a collection piece by piece. The teen-focused kit and other all-in-one options list combinations of complexion, eye, lip, and tool items, which can provide a starting assortment. The tradeoff is that a beginner may not know which shades or formulas suit them, and a very broad kit can feel harder to use than a smaller palette. I would check the included shades and whether the recipient will use the foundation and tools. Someone who wants a simple first routine may be better served by a more focused set.
Should I choose the Revolution Advent Calendar or a regular all-in-one kit?
Choose the Revolution Advent Calendar if presentation and discovering a range of products are part of the appeal. A regular all-in-one kit is a better match when the recipient wants a grouped assortment of makeup categories and tools for ongoing use. The calendar format is distinctive for gifting, but variety does not necessarily mean every item will become part of a daily routine. Compare the listed contents with what the recipient already uses rather than choosing by format alone. If practical coverage matters more than the gift experience, a targeted kit may fit better.
Is a full-face palette more useful than a kit with separate products and brushes?
That depends on whether the buyer values a compact, coordinated format or a wider selection of product types. The LAURA GELLER Best of the Best Baked Palette is the lineup’s palette-led choice, while options such as the MTDXILTAI kit list separate products alongside a large brush set. A palette can be easier to store and keep together, but may offer less variety across categories. A larger kit can cover more steps, though it may take more space and require the user to sort through more items. Match the format to storage, routine, and how much variety the recipient will actually use.
What should I check before buying a makeup set online for someone else?
Start with the recipient’s preferred makeup style, complexion shade needs, and whether they already own brushes or palettes. Then review the exact contents and shade descriptions instead of relying on the set’s name or advertised item count. Look for a format that makes sense for the occasion: a gift-focused calendar, a compact palette, or a broad starter assortment. If the recipient has sensitive skin or ingredient preferences, check the product details rather than assuming all sets suit everyone. When key details such as shade range are unclear, choose a set whose value does not depend on an uncertain complexion match.
Conclusion
For most shoppers wanting a focused, versatile format, I recommend the LAURA GELLER Best of the Best Baked Palette as the best overall pick in this lineup. The clearest value choice is the Sephora Favorites Prep & Set for shoppers who specifically want skincare and primer essentials, while the Revolution Advent Calendar is my best gift-oriented pick for someone who enjoys variety. Beginners who want multiple product categories in one package should compare the teen-focused set with the other all-in-one kits, checking shade fit and tools before choosing; there is no single best beginner kit for every complexion or routine. For shoppers who prioritize a large assortment, the MTDXILTAI set or 40-color kit may suit experimentation, while the compact palette makes more sense for a streamlined routine. Pick the format that matches the person’s actual makeup habits, not simply the set with the most listed pieces.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
